6 of one, half a dozen of the other. Have had fewer issues with Philly. We usually like to go with a longer connection time. In the past our flights leaving SXM have caused us to miss our connection in CLT. Plus we have encountered LONG lines there with immigration/customs. Philly is closer to home so if something happens (i.e. missed flight) we can always rent a car and drive home.

[Linked Image]
[/url]