We always stay a night in Cinnamon Bay - usually the first night out from CA and sometimes even our last night (we check in with C&I in Cruz Bay then go back to Cinnamon for the night). We enjoy it - very quite. Only downside is that for a mono it always seems a bit rolly especially if it's a first night before you've gained your sea legs. Cats seem to be flat as a pancake so probably no problem if you are sailing one of those.