We also use AAA and have been happy. For us we take a cab when we land - Wilfred Brooks - and have the car dropped the next day or so by AAA where we are staying - always on time. We prefer not having to deal with a rental the 1st day and let Wilfred take care of us. The AAA drop is easy, we just give a time and the car appears, quick walk around, sign and we are done

Works for us
J&B