Put the Grenadines on your bucket list, too. I like it a tad better than the BVI's. The best description I've heard is that its like the BVI's were 25 or 30 years ago. Although, since Sunsail and Moorings moved their bases out of St.Vincent/Canoun, it's harder to make work logistically. There are 2nd tier companies in St. Vincent that are supposed to be very good. However, since we only charter in the Caribbean every two or three years, I'd rather pay for a boat that's less than two years old. Just trying to reduce the odds that something major breaks.
Enjoy showing the newbies the BVI!