I think it really depends on where you are travelling to. I would never do an AI in SXM and can't even think about recommending anyone to do so. In SXM it is easy and safe to get around, there are great beaches, and way to many delicious restaurants to try. In Mexico however, I love doing an AI. It's nice once and awhile to be pampered that way but I wouldn't enjoy it every trip. You really do need to go to a high end AI however to get the really great food, service, drinks etc.....