Thank you everyone for your comments and suggestions. The boat is a 45 foot Leopard Catamaran; cruising speed of 7 to 9 knots. We are limited to five nights and can not change the departure destination. Our captain said we would anchor in Christmas Cove the first night and also stated that the desired trip could be done, given effective weather conditions. I was just trying to gain more insight into what an itinerary with Anegada would look like. Sounds like the majority suggests more than a 5 night sail. We, however, don't want to visit several of the places we've already visited multiple times so we thought Anegada would be a nice replacement. We don't mind sailing for 2 - 3 hours at a time, but it seems as though I've misjudged how long it takes to get from one island to another.
.
