correct that going to different restaurants can make it seem like a totally different island. Recently did a 2 week trip with 2 groups, each x 1 week. We stopped at many of the same islands but it seemed different island to me due to resturant/bar selection.
For instance, JVD with Great Harbor and Foxxy's... spend go out and come in White Bay ...seems different... go out and come around to Little Harbor and eat at Sydney's Peace & Love...