You will get different opinions from different visitors. Our group does enjoy the hospitality of Peter Island. For our group than means a long relaxing lunch and for a few the spa. We call in advance and determine which days during our visit will work best for Peter Island. If you just show up on a day when the resort is full with overnight visitors or short staffed for the events planned you may be disappointed. Please consider most of the overnight visitors on Peter Island are spending $1,000 or much more per day. There are days when the resort takes many of the guests away from the island. On the days when many of the guests are elsewhere we have found the service to be spectacular. We have found calling ahead would better in any of the higher quality venues across the BVI. I would strongly suggest a shirt with collar and a proper shoe on arrival.