Fair1976 said: This is precisely why I posted this question. My opinions have varied as much as the ones I've read. At first, we were dead set on Anegada but started rethinking it...now I'm rethinking my rethinking.
I wouldn't over think it. See how the weather is, see what the group feels like and make the decision while there.
Overthinking it was a big part of the fun planning our early BVI trips.