First, I will concede that we are in the minority but prefer Caribbean over Maine lobster. Before you beat us up, let me say that my sister in law lived in Maine for a number of years and we had lots of fresh lobster there and when they brought it to us in PA. Some SXM restaurants have ignored my request for lobster without garlic, that I cannot have, since most folks prefer garlic with lobster. We have found Chesterfield's $40+ lobster to be our favorite when they have it.