IMHO, there are any number of incredible destinations in the Caribbean. Right now at the very top of the list is St. Kitts & Curacao. We were just at both Islands weeks ago and what stood out the most were the people, incredibly friendly, great restaurants and entertainment, the accommodations were fantastic. We will not stay at any resort that has to provide 24 hour armed guards and quietly informs you with an odd look about where to shop and when. We absolutely love St. Maarten and pray for everyone affected by the devastating events this past years. We have stayed at the Esmeralda Resort on Orient Bay since 2002 and couldn't have planned any better vacations than we experienced there and at the various restaurants, except for one on the hill. watching the videos of the destruction of that Island was heartbreaking. I personally have very mixed feelings about returning too soon as the Islanders are attempting to rebuild, pathetic Government leadership has shone a brilliant spotlight on itself as people are striving to rebuild. Fancy suits spewing empty promises, ridiculous court proceedings for the criminals that stole from their own leaves questions concerning the commitment of those in power as to what they really are looking for.
So lastly, if you do choose Jamaica, bring water shoes to traverse Dunn's River Falls, very very slippery.