I've been looking into other ideas for future trips too. I'd like to try Guadeloupe, but travel is a problem. I was recently reading about chartering out of Key West and visiting Marquesas and Dry Tortugas. I'm sailing in the BVI's in a couple of months. After that trip I will probably start looking into other locations more seriously. I love the BVI, but the cost are getting too high. The travel cost right now is really high. ATL to STT is about $1000 right now. We're flying SJU to EIS an it was actually $200-ish cheaper. ATL to FLL is maybe $200, but then you have to rent a car or take a shuttle to Key West. Still, I think I could do a Key West trip for $1500-$2000 per couple cheaper than the upcoming BVI trip.