1) Only been to Club F, but I think there was only one other couple there the (one) time we went.

2) View is very important to me, and a pool and convenient parking and road access The driveway and parking at Club F is a PITA.
Event coordinator for a c/o place?? LOL.. Don't think that would be important to most anyone
C/O excursions would be I guess you mean boat trips? Those can get pretty pricy, if you would be limiting it only to those in the villa.. Wouldn't be important to me.

I want
Good internet!
TV in the bedroom
Small fridge in the bedroom
High end bedding and towels
Continental breakfast is fine, not cooked
Would be nice to maybe have one night per week where there is a cooked meal for dinner and most people who are staying there participate
Don't care about open bar so long as I have my own fridge in the room.