Congratulations on your win. If I’m not mistaken, Maho Sonesta is an AI Resort, or at least, it was. If still the case, please don’t let that tie you completely to the resort. In the area I would highly recoded La Moulin Fou and La RosaToo. While not really what I’d call seafood restaurants, all their food is delicious..

In the Simpson Bay area and not too very far away, we have always had good seafood at Skipjacks Restaurant and most specifically, their lobster has always been excellent in our experience. It’s a pretty setting and based on our last few visits, I would recommend a reservation, particularly if you want a water side table. We love to contemplate and dream about all the beautiful yachts moored in the area - where they’ve traveled and what member of the rich and famous population might have traveled on them.