We've done BVI many times, then sailed the Grenadines (which I recommend over SVI), went back to the BVI 's....sailed SVI's last year, then got home and immediately booked a trip back to the BVI!

We are super glad we went to the SVI, had a great time, it was nice, sailing was a bit rough and uncomfortable, nice anchorages, but VERY secluded. But couldn't help miss the BVI. I would always suggest trying something new, but if you are like us, you'll be back in the BVI!