If you don't mind paying a little more, another possibility for a one night stay is Holland House right in Philipsburg. A lot of people who have taken cruises from St. Maarten stay there for a night or two prior to their cruise because the port is right next door. It has a lot going for it including a great breakfast buffet each morning, a beautiful outdoor restaurant that overlooks Great Bay and includes a view of Saba from the tiered levels, excellent security, and it's located mid way between the airport and the Oyster Pond area. It's just a 20 minute drive from Holland House (northeast) to reach your destination. Plus, super friendly staff makes this a nice choice. May be able to get a room for about $176/night, but you'll have to research this to find the best deal. My wife and I have stayed here several times in past years and have loved it every time.