Sammy has summed up Palm Court very nicely.
We have stayed there twice and will probably be our choice this year for our first week.
Last time there was a week before Irma hit and I can remember being in the pool talking about a possible storm crossing the Atlantic.
The redo of the complex looks wonderful,
We have stayed there during the third week of August and almost always have the afternoon pool to ourselves.
The included continental is sufficient.
Short stroll to beach and the village for nice meals.
Grand Case is about 10 minutes away, while L'Astrolab and Sole e Luna are also extremely close.
The ferry to pinel isle is within 10 minutes.
Gated parking is very secure.
Best price I found for Palm Court which included taxes and fees was through West Indes Travel under trip advisor.

My wife had picked out the beautiful Orient Beach Hotel which offers ocean view if that is important.
I'll use the saved rental dollars / euros and put it to the meal fund.
Can never have enough to spend on food and wine.

I'm sure either choice will be wonderful.