While Frank gives some good information, his list is not comprehensive, he acknowledges he doesn't even like St Thomas and he leans heavily on Trip Advisor reviews.
For St Thomas recommendations, ask St Thomians.
Hi Nutmeg... You are absolutely right about the best resource being STT folks. There are surely other options, but my list has been compiled over the years strictly from TTOL'ers positive recommendations, not because of TripAdvisor reviews. I only included those review links to help the reader - the reviews actually vary quite a bit, but they can often include some good info about the places. e.g. if 10 people say the steps to a hotel are very steep, then they probably are.
I am not being defensive (really!), but whether or not I like St. Thomas has had no effect on the list. If you or any other TTOL'ers have some accommodations that would be valuable to add to the list, please let me know. The whole point is to provide a useful resource.
