I think it all depends on what you're looking for. Party boat with a lot of different stops - Random Wind. If you're looking to actually sail - No1 SXM. Our sunset sail was so quiet and peaceful, just the sound of the wind and waves, quiet conversation with just 2 other couples. Perfection. On the day sail, they only go to one island, Tintamarre. Pieter explained that having an itinerary with a lot of stops, as Random Wind does, necessitates motoring vs. sailing. That was our experience as well. We thought we signed up for a sail on Random Wind and other than the first leg, we motored the entire day.