Your timeline is a bit off. The first WillyT was sunk long ago off Great Harbor near the wreck of the Fearless. The second WillyT was always in the Bight. It was beached there by Irma. It was eventually pulled off and sunk near Key Bay on Peter. The third WillyT was built and placed back in the Bight. The owners of the island wanted it gone and managed to somehow get their seabed license revoked. It was then moved to Great Harbor on Peter. The Bight became a ghost town and Great Harbor boomed. The owners realized that Pirates was in trouble and their mooring revenue dropped like a stone. They had a change of heart and the WillyT was returned to the Bight. I can’t imagine the Owners of Oceans wanted them gone as it should have been a huge boost to them.