Agree.

We are currently on Sea Tiger and going thru San Juan. We had a 4 hr delay on morning flight from San Juan (beautiful weather) after overnighting in SJU.

Also return flight, after booking and several weeks before travel, our return trip got changed for departure from SJU to ATL to add an overnight stay in San Juan. Fortunately, my present schedule can allow this.

I would suggest STT (which we usually do) and perhaps overnight in STT if you choose. Water taxi for your group or ferry