We absolutely loved our stays on AXA though they were a few years ago now. Personally speaking and I hope none of our friends and fellow SXM lovers take offense, I think the AXA beaches are even nicer than most of the ones on SXM but the logistics suck. And the nightlife just isn’t there if that’s important to you. To us, not so much.
Wishing you good flights and fun travels. And an awesome time on both islands. Happy Turkey day!