We did the same thing. Went to DSR for a few visits, loved it there, but decided we should try other places to see what we might be missing.

We visited Terra Cotta, Sea Mountain and Living Waters.

We regretted Sea Mountain and would warn anybody about their mischaracterizations on the internet.

Living Waters was very small, very European and "healing" waterish.

Terra Cotta had very nice owners and big rooms. We left a night early, paid for the night we didn't stay there because we wanted to be fair, and went back to DSR.

We satisfied our curiosity and are still thrilled with DSR.