We finally tried Pizza Italy for the first time last year near the end of our 22 day stay and we were pretty much overdone with gourmet meals.

I know we enjoyed a calzone and declined the complimentary bread only for the server to insist.
It was crazy good and the same dough was used in the preparation for the calzone making that excellent as well.

What I remember most was the friendly service
.
They also have house made gelato but unfortunately none was available on our visit maybe because it was slow season.

Not fancy but good food

On our list for this August / September