Instead of breaking your tie I would confuse it more by adding Grand Case Beach Club. Check web site for all their info.

I don't know how it compares to the other places price wise but the place is on a peninsular overlooking Anguilla. So it has access to Grand Case Beach which goes into town plus a smaller beach on the other side. Sunset Cafe separates the two. They have free water sports and transportation into town if you can't make the short walk.

If you decide not to stay there you can go to the cafe for happy hour and fantastic sunset view.