Yep. No doubt about it. The anchorage at Trellis Bay has that run-down, trailer-trash sort of look to it. Lots of neglected boats, some that make you wonder how they stay afloat.

Still, there are lots of days when the mooring field at Marina Cay will be very rolly while the anchorage at Trellis Bay is quiet and peaceful. The shops and restaurants on shore at Trellis Bay are also--to me and my wife, at least--very well worth it. Even when we have moored at Marina Cay we usually take the dinghy over to Trellis Bay for a visit.

If you can get past the "wrong side of the tracks" look to the anchorage, in my opinion Trellis Bay is very definitely worth a visit. If you're only going to be there one night, I might choose Marina Cay, but my best advice is to find time for both.

(Never stayed at Scrub Island, so I cannot comment on that.)