I'm on the fence honestly. I agree I'm not wild about clearing customs so many times over a 8 day period, but if I can make it relatively painless we might do it. Realistically I don't want to spend the half day to visit a place I wouldn't normally plan on visiting. I wasn't planning on visiting Sopers on this trip, but if we visit St John then we'd probably come back through there then to Norman or Peter. Going I think I can jiggle our plans around to visit JVD then head to St John so going isn't that much of an issue.
I'm still thinking through this....Thanks again for all the help. I don't think I'm going to go wrong either way!