We have only stayed at the Alamanda. We stayed there for four years and when we decided to increase our vacation time, opted for a villa in the hills above Orient, since the price was less than the Alamanda. The Alamanda is conveniently located with Orient Village right next door. The beach is directly in front of you. You could stay at the Alamanda and never need to rent a car. We always did since we enjoy exploring the island, but if all you wanted was a beach and dining experience, you could do that at the Alamanda without a car.