And one other suggestion: Anse Marcel Beach. Their restaurant provides food on a par with Dreams. They are also right on the beach, and the sand is much nicer there than in Nettle Bay. However, I agree with the others: if you contact Bruno and mention TTOL, you likely will get a top-notch experience.

Dreams website

And it looks as though Anse Marcel finally has their website up and running although I couldn't add it in the same way as Dreams above: http://www.ansemarcelbeach.com/index.html