We are flying out today after our first week ever visiting anywhere in the Caribbean (we chose St. Martin). We've had great weather and stayed on the Dutch side, but spent our days on the French side. We'd give Anse Marcel a slight nod over Orient Beach, mainly due to calmer water and no sargassum, but we alternated and loved both. Favorite restaurants: La Trattoria and Calmos Cafe. Everyone was great to us and we look forward to coming back. Thanks to everyone who offered advice prior to our trip.