We have chartered in BVI for 30 years. Many trips have been with one or two other couples, but we have also done some "just us" trips. I have to say that I love the quiet not in a hurry to show someone something pace of "just us". BVIYC has a lot of boats that would fit your needs. We have taken their newer 41 Beneteau "Tootsie" several times and just love the way it sails. Very comfy for one couple.

The first time we did "just us" I really wondered if I would have anything to talk to the hub about after a while. We had 10 days on boat, then 10 days on VG. It was just a perfect trip. No expectations, just floating on a sea of blue, swimming, dingy dinking etc. We are planning our next year trip now!!