We haven't been to all of them, but it's Nanny Cay for me - as long as there is A/C on the boat. Great showers, nice big pool, on-site restaurant and a couple good provisioning options nearby. And Horizon has always been great to deal with when we've used them in the past. Only downside is it's a bit further from the airport than some of the other bases.

We also like Soper's Hole as there is plenty for the crew to do while we're going through the checkout procedures and a decent store that is walkable for provisioning. Also a nice place for a sleepaboard. And it's always a treat to be on a Voyage boat.

That said, the base is one of the last things that we consider when chartering a boat. Availability, boat model and year, amenities on the boat, price, charter company reputation, and overall condition of the boat are all the primary factors we prioritize. If all of those are a toss up between two companies then the base may come into play.

Matt