Eric really liked Carrefour this time, but I agree with you about the smell. I prefer Super U, which is in Marigot, or Grand Marche, which is by the roundabout where Mark's is. Super U is EXTREMELY clean and there have been several studies done showing their prices are the lowest on the island. The only knock on them is that you don't find many American products, like chips, etc., there, and it helps if you know some French, as all the labels are in French. Grand Marche has lots of US products and the labels are in English. The Market Garden is closest to you, but I think their prices are very high, especially for wine, and I don't think their selection is very good. As someone said though, unless you're eating in all your meals, Market Garden would probably do. We cook in a LOT and grocery shopping is part of the fun for me!