Everyone will have a diff take bc that BVI vibe cant be created b4 you get there but the question prob comes down to how long is your charter? If you have a 14 day charter, doesnt really matter does it but I often only get 5-7 day trips and while it takes a little more effort to get to Tortola, as soon as I hit it the vaca starts whereas when I have chartered out of USVI is really nice but just waiting till I get to BVI. Just MHO smile.

"these are the issues worth grappling about in life!!!"