What are your dates? We are flying to SJU on Jet Blue from Orlando and then using our Intercaribbean flights that we booked for November to EIS. One way on JB for “Even More Space” seats non stop was $250 each. JB doesn’t have our return date up yet but hoping to use points for that.

We used Intercaribbean on our last trip in May and had a good experience with them - they were less $$$ than Seaborne and Cape Air.
We have to collect bags and go through security so I allow at least two hours even with TSA precheck and Global Entry on the return.

On a sad note...the boat we have wanted to charter for a while now was destroyed in Irma’s wrath...but on a happy note, BVI Yacht Charters has said they are replacing it with a brand new Jeanneau 2c/2h with Gen/AC which is likely the 44DS....not too shabby!!!