Great report! We loved our dinner at Pineapple Pete's as well! I am a Lobster Thermidor girl and it did not disappoint! I look forward to it every year as our first meal on the island! We also love Driftwood (avoiding Sunset like the plague). Their rum punches are amazing but very strong and we always get their pizza! Service is friendly. We have never had their burgers but with comments here would probably avoid ordering them. We drove by one day and saw a couple good friends at the bar. Of course we HAD to stop for a rum punch. Amazingly we were able to pull right into a spot next to the bar. Unheard of! We stayed at Marys Boon last year and loved it there. Everyone was so friendly and we loved being on the beach. Sadly, the unit we stayed in was destroyed by Irma. Hope they will consider rebuilding those units. Thanks for sharing your adventure with us! (Makes me a little homesick!)