[/quote]
In my opinion, Maine lobster is always bland compared to the succulent Anegada spiny lobster. I've never eaten cardboard, so I'm not sure if I would like it or not.[/quote]

Clearly a matter of taste. My guess is that people from the northeast would prefer Maine lobster and folks from the tropics, spiny lobster. Fortunately, there are plenty of food options in the BVI, so everyone can be happy.