Hi, Tim,

Hope you’re going to be there for at least two weeks as that’s a very aggressive travel plan but each of those islands is different and so worth seeing. My favorite of the three is Saba but only because it is so very different from the others and reminds me a lot of St. Maarten (without the beaches) when we first visited in the early 70s.

Without a doubt, and as others have suggested, Simpson Bay gives you more walking ops to bars and restaurants and more activity in general. That said, my personal taste would be for Divi but only because I like having a quiet place to come home to at the end of my busy island days and it is a very pretty area.