Flightaware gets confused, but it reports what it can. I can't speak to the accuracy, bet her's what I see:

AAL 886 dep SXM 11/10 20:09 arr MIA 21:57

Then there's an unusual AA flight number , AAL 9202 on the night of the 11th.

AAL 9202 dep MIA 11/11 12:04, arr CLT 02:44

That second flight may have been a special flight for the SXM-CLT passengers.