FYI.... I tried to get a fishing license through Island Surf and Sail (BVI Water toys) and got the reply from them below,

“BVI Government Fisheries changed the application process for the fishing permit applications. We no longer offer that service. Please email fisheries @gov.vg for instructions and application form.

The fishing permit application process have changed
Apply online to email fisheries@gov.vg (application form and passport)
BVI Fisheries process permit
BVI Fisheries email a permit number to applicant
Applicant enters the BVI and passport is stamped by Immigration
Applicant emails photo of Immigration entry stamp to fisheries@gov.vg
BVI Fisheries email applicant the fishing permit”

I am now attempting to obtain a license as stated above. Hope it works............