Agree. we would select Marina Cay...... ...we have found, the moorings on the South West area of the Mooring Field, seem to be in better condition . Three weeks ago.

Id you need to get over to Trellis for some provisions, you can hop on the free scheduled, small ferry that runs between Trellis, Marina Cay, and Scrub Island.....keeps life easy.. And your crew can head for what feels good to them.

We just spent a couple of days at marina cay, and looked at it from a positive stand point. The dining area under the roof of a protective tent is just fine. We sat up at the bar. .
The bar is adjacent to the dining area. Friendly, easy going, good service, great view, etc. There is a dock master to help you with water, ice, etc. .

Marina cay is very pleasant and protected by the reef.

Also, if heading TO Jost or Cane Garden after marina cay, you may want to stop enroute at Monkey Point, at Guana Island. NP moorings and good snorkeling. We drop of early at Marina Cay..

Also, we like to motor from Marina Cay via the Camanoe Passage. to Monkey point, Charge up the batteries at the same time.

Just FYI.