If you're looking for three weeks in April or May, I figure you might be able to get a deal on Canoua, for a longer period of time like that, IF they have availability. You can look at their calendar for next year and see. Canoua definitely has a VERY private pool. I have started on a review of Canoua, which I hope maybe to be able to post this weekend, not sure.

Regarding Simpson Bay versus Happy Bay, uhmn, totally different. I gather you've never been to SXM before?? I think you should do some reading here on the board, to decide what area of the island would be better. Happy Bay is on the French side and is 5 minutes from Grand Case and Orient Village. Happy Bay is a beach that is totally inaccessible, except on foot. There are no facilities there, other than one fellow who comes in and cooks there occasionally. Happy Bay is walking distance from Canoua, yes, if you are pretty physically fit. I did not attempt the walk, as I have knee issues. Simpson Bay AREA is the most built up on SXM. There are many bars, restaurants, and casinos in that area.

I'm unclear when you're talking about the location of this other villa you are thinking about. Can you give an actual listing for the property? To ME, I doubt I would want to be in that area, if it is where I think it is, as it would be a fair distance drive to restaurants at night.