Thanks for all of the advice. google flights set up to help track. definitely don't plan on booking too soon, just a little bit of sticker shock as i start tracking the fares. We haven't been down to the BVIs in 7 years and moderately excited, even 11 months out, to get back.

I appreciate the heads up on Jet Blue through SJU. We've only taken the ferry out of STT and have been lucky enough to never have issues. We're bringing two couples who have never been to the BVIs, so its great having options.