We used Barry and L&M Rentals. $95 daily rater + $15 gas refill for a Dodge minivan for our party of 5 worked just fine. They had scooters as well as smaller vehicles. L&M opens at 8:30 AM "Island time" which meant 9-ish but rental was quick and easy with friendly woman helping us. You can get a free ride to & from Anegada Beach Club. It's co-located with Potters by the Sea and is where we had our lobster dinner.