Kelly is better reached by facebook or text....

https://www.facebook.com/AnegadaTours/

My commentary re:Kelly is above and still valid IMHO. If only in Anegada for a day and haven't been before and will snorkel elsewhere in the islands I might suggest rent a jeep or take taxi and go to Flash of beauty in the AM to snorkel and skip boat tour. Those that dont want to snorkel can be dropped off at Loblolly (you can also snorkel there). Those that snorkel can walk to Loblolly after snorkling and meet up. In the afternoon take the car to Cow Wreck Beach and enjoy the sunset at my favorite bar at the end of the world

All IMHO