Both are good...D"Coal Pot is a little cheaper but great menu with many options ( and they serve the Ginger Wine Chicken from the old Palm's Delight and Skyworld before that) For that alone its worth trying! If you have been to Bananakeet then maybe time to try D'Coal Pot. I'd be tempted to get the cab driver to take you to The Sugar Mill first for a happy hour drink in the upstairsbar (Vicky makes the worlds' best Margarita) and then take you back for dinner at D'Coal Pot (unless you then look at The Sugar Mill menus..up and beachfront and decide to stay there)