We are planning our first sailing trip to BVI this summer. We are a group of 7 - all new at this but looking forward to the adventure of an 8 day sail. We have narrowed the choice to 2 charter companies with different boat options. Need some opinions please.

Boat 1 - Bali 4.5
Boat 2 - Lagoon 450

We will have a captain with us for a total of 8 people.

Thanks in advance