Café Roma has always been a favorite glad they are reopened. Love Rumb Lines. I don't really like the Beach Bar. I want to but can't get past the bad service. High Tide or Joe's is better service in the same location. I also prefer Shipwreck's food to Skinny's. Fish and Chips are awesome. The Lime Inn is always solid. La Tapa is great but not inexpensive. There have been several changes this season. ZoZo's moved to Caneel Bay. La Plancha went out of business and was replaced by a new place run by the Sun Dog Café people should be good, in Mongoose Junction. One of the brothers that owned Woody's opened a new place where JJ's used to be after they sold Woody's. There is also a new place in ZoZo's location at Gallows. We also like The Banana Deck as well. With a group your size for the nicer places you are going to want a reservation.
Jay