Katie and Ben,

While it is not on your choice list, the Queen's Garden Inn is lovely and while you might be put off by their listed prices on their website, we contacted them directly with our dates and they put together a special packaged price for us and added a few breakfasts and a dinner at our request. it worked out to be far more reasonable than their listed rack rates and the stay was wonderful.

We've referred quite a few SXMers and to date each of them has been well satisfied with their stays. If you check out caribbeanscouts prolog to her trip report she has posted a couple of photos that would paint a better picture than my words could ever do.

I will add the staff is very accommodating both in finding better air prices than we could find and in providing concierge services for a few restaurant reservations. Oh! Their restaurant is excellent, too.