That's an interesting question, a sit down dinner, versus heavy appetizers, it is kind of a different thing.. It would be more complicated for anyone to do, with that many people, for a sit down dinner versus heavy appetizers. Our experience with Fabulous Feasts was a sit down dinner, but it was just the two of us. I know that Richard from Gutside does catering for groups, but it is a whole different thing, Caribbean dishes, on a buffet. If it were ME, I'd opt for Dino, if the price was relatively the same, as he is truly one of the best chefs in the Caribbean. And no, he didn't pay me anything to say that!!! Anyway, best wishes with your choice!!